C.I.A. Ran Secret Prisons in Poland and Romania

That is the finding of a report prepared for the Council of Europe, a coalition of countries that monitors human rights:

The CIA ran secret jails in Poland and Romania to interrogate key terror suspects, shackling and handcuffing inmates, keeping some naked for weeks, and reducing contact with the outer world to masked and silent guards, a European investigator said yesterday.

The CIA called the report “distorted,” but stopped short of denying the existence of such prisons. The agency said it does not discuss the location of its overseas facilities. Poland and Romania also vehemently denied the allegations.

“High value detainees” like self-proclaimed 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and suspected senior Al Qaeda operative Abu Zubaydah were held in Poland, said the report, which cited CIA sources. It said lesser detainees, but still of “remarkable importance,” were taken to Romania.

[…]

The report said its conclusions about the clandestine prisons relied on “multiple sources which validate and corroborate one another.” Marty said his team spoke with “over 30 one-time members of intelligence services in the United States and Europe” as well as former or current detainees and human rights activists.

While conceding at a news conference that sources for the report were limited, Marty said they were “well placed,” including some who “were implicated.”

The alleged prisons were at the center of a “spider’s web” of purported human rights abuses that Marty outlined in his initial investigation a year ago.

That report focused on flights to spirit detainees to CIA hideouts with landing points in at least 14 nations.

Clandestine prisons and secret CIA flights involving European countries would breach the continent’s human rights treaties, although the Council of Europe has no power to punish countries. The council, which is separate from the European Union, was set up four years after World War II to promote democracy, human rights, and the rule of law in Europe.

[…]

CIA spokesman Paul Gimigliano did not address whether there were secret detention centers, but he disputed the report’s characterization of the agency’s activities.

“When you see words like apartheid and torture in the document, that tells you it’s biased and distorted,” he said. “The CIA’s counterterror operations have been lawful, effective, closely reviewed, and of benefit to many people — including Europeans — in disrupting plots and saving lives. Our counterterror partnerships in Europe are very strong.”

Gimigliano is a liar. Note I did not say he is wrong. That would imply a mistake made in good faith. But that is not the case. Gimigliano knows as well as he knows his own name that secret prisons are illegal by definition. Secret prisons cannot be reviewed, closely or otherwise, because they’re secret. No one knows where they are. No one knows who is being held in them. To suggest that C.I.A. “reviews” of interrogation practices in its own clandestine facilities, with no independent oversight of those “reviews,” could possibly be legitimate, is beyond absurd, beyond outrageous. The contempt such a claim reveals for ordinary common sense, not to mention what the law requires, truly takes one’s breath away.

Cross-posted at Liberty Street.

Advertisements

12 Comments

Filed under 05_kathy

12 responses to “C.I.A. Ran Secret Prisons in Poland and Romania

  1. “When you see words like apartheid and torture in the document, that tells you it’s biased and distorted” …

    That’s a nifty trick: use of the word “torture” signifies bias; therefore any charges of “torture” that use the word “torture” can be instantly dismissed as unfounded and not worthy of engagement.

  2. a liar in the CIA?? Surely you jest!

  3. Ivory Bill Woodpecker

    If I had to travel outside the USA for some reason, I would pretend to be Canadian, eh? 😉

  4. jahf

    Note I did not say he is wrong. That would imply a mistake made in good faith. But that is not the case.

    This crucial point is true generally of what this country has accepted as its executive leadership, and is also one that people generally miss.

  5. Ivory Bill Woodpecker

    What Jahf said. The whole modern USAmerican “conservative” movement resembles nothing else so much as a criminal syndicate. 😦

  6. The whole modern USAmerican “conservative” movement resembles nothing else so much as a criminal syndicate.

    i believe you’ve got it slightly wrong there IBW. Sub “Is” for “resembles” and you’ll have it correct. BASTARDS!

  7. “Gimigliano is a liar.”

    Thank you for not mincing words here. I’m so fucking sick of terms like “untruths” and “misrepresentations” and, heaven forbid, “falsifications.”

    They’re LIES. The pResident LIES. The Vice pResident LIES. They lie to us, they lie to Congress, they lie to the United Nations. THEY LIE.

    IMPEACH, God dammit! It’s not an option, IT’S AN OBLIGATION. The Constitution demands it. If Pelosi and Reid won’t do it, IMPEACH THEIR ASSES AND REPLACE THEM WITH SOMEONE WHO WILL.

  8. Ivory Bill Woodpecker

    How CAN the Chimperor or Darth Cheney be removed when the Democrats don’t have a majority to convict? The Dems would need a number of GOP senators to defect, and today’s GOP resembles an old-style Communist party in its internal discipline. 😦

  9. “The CIA’s counterterror operations have been lawful,

    Translation: They didn’t break American law on American soil.

    God, I hope someone in Europe starts issuing arrest warrents.

  10. IBW, they have the numbers to conduct serious investigations, and when the light hits the dirt, real republicans will be a soutraged as WE are, the public will demand action, and the pressure will be on ALL House and Senate members to go with impeachment.

    I wrote some thoughts on it here: http://littlebangtheory.wordpress.com/2007/06/08/scott-ritter-on-defense-of-the-constitution/#comments

  11. It’s not an option, IT’S AN OBLIGATION.

    Fucking right, it is!

  12. Pingback: Daily Round-Up at Shakesville

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s